I am kind of in a similar boat.
Anyway, I picked up a broken hot tub as I'm retired and like challenges.
After fixing the known broken pipe and discovering the one seeping leak after the first cleaning and verifying the pump worked, I found (and wasn't surprised) the the control system was completely dead.
We really didn't care because we were more interested in using it as a dip pool.
Well I got it working so well, I became interested in repairing or replacing the control system.
I found out from the spa dealer, and the manufacturer of the control system (Balboa) that the typical life spa of a control system is measured in LOW SINGLE DIGIT YEARS. One said 5 years max, the other said 3.
Well, Balboa suggested putting a retro fit kit in and suggested a model number on their website, but to my surprise they directed me to a third party that sells their product because I could buy it for $300 less from the third party - so we are talking about $450.
So I talked it over with the other half, and she said go ahead.
So I asked Balboa for an installation manual to show my plumber and electrician and they simply refused to supply one. Which made me look for someone that would be more helpful. Using Google I found AcuraSpa and they were happy to supply manuals, drawings and answer all of my questions. On top of it, they warrant their product for 5 years, the guy I talked to has been doing this for 30 years and better yet, cost under $400 with a few upgrades.
You might want to take a step back and not try to figure out why what you have doesn't work and just gut it.