I know it has been a long time since you posted this, but I bought a tub about 4 months ago and loved it for about 2 months then I had the same issue you described. I'm a man and have reluctantly tryed my tube after waiting several weeks to get over itchy nipples that I try scratching off my body. One night soak for 30 minutes and it comes right back. No problem while in tub, shower as soon as I get out, lotion up and about 2 hours later it starts. Sorry for this long story, just really want to know if you figured out what was causing your issue?
