Do you by chance live in Virginia? I too have a floating liner problem with a pool that is 10 years old. I have tried french drains, in-ground sump pumps, and wells - all at a total cost of about $4000 - and nothing has worked. My pool installer has turned their back on me. Seems pool installers make so much money installing that they won't pay attention to anything else, even if it's the right thing to do. I recently found out that I have a cavity (hole) under the sidewalk and down around the pool wall. I covered the entire area with a tarp and the liner has not floated in situations where in normally would float. I am certain that the cavity is drawing & holding the water that is causing the liner to float. My plan is to put sand into the cavity, which will hopefully solve my problem. If you notice slight holes, burrows or "tunnels" at the edge of your sidewalk, you my have a cavity underneath. If you suspect a cavity, dig down next to the sidewalk and it will show up.