I was going to post in "swim spas" but was worried I wouldn't get the benefit of all your hot tub expertise..!!
1. Background
I've had my "Endless Pool" for 12 years. I am on my 4th circulation pump.
It was shipped with a Laing E14 low power pump, running 24/7 (controlled by a Gecko in.xe). There is only 6 feet of plumbing so seemed fine.
The E14 pumps seem to last about 3 years between failure. The failures seems quite consistent - a grinding noise when starting and then refusal to run. Sounds quite similar to https://www.poolspaforum.com/forum/index.php?/topic/48883-master-spas-multiple-circuit-pump-failures/
2. Heat Pump
Anyways.. I've recently added an air source heat pump (Gecko in.temp & in.ye) and another 20 feet of plumbing. My 3rd E14 failed soon after. Possibly related to the extra load.. or maybe it had just done it's 3 years of 24/7 service.
So for my 4th pump I've gone for a simpler, cheaper, more powerful traditional pump (250 watts compared to the E14's 108 watts)
https://www.poolandspacentre.co.uk/products/wtc50m-circulation-pump.html
Questions
Q1. What contributes to the lifespan of a pump? Is it total run time, or does starting / stopping the pump add extra trauma to the pump? I expect chemistry plays a part. I keep a reasonable ph level but I am far from obsessive about chemistry, so I expect my pumps could suffer a bit.
Q2. I am thinking the OEM 24/7 circulation pump cycle was possibly a bit overkill and I am OK to reduce this significantly. The new pump can move 240 litres/min. And my pool is only used for 1hr 3x per week. In theory the new pump can circulate the full pool every hour. So how about activating the pump for 1 hr evening, 1 hr morning? Is that enough? And is 2 x 1hr causing twice as much cycling trauma on the pump than 1 x 2hr?
(The 2 hrs circulation would be in addition to the circulation that takes place whilst heating. I activate the heating for a couple of hours before my swims to boost up the temp to around 23 celcius. Then turn off heating until the next swim day)