Thanks for the info. I'll test again tonight or tomorrow and post all the numbers. The pool was filled with drinking water, and I began testing a day or so after it was filled. I've never seen any Chlorine numbers so I doubt it's from algea, but who know. I've been shocking it very often as is (maybe 6 times so far?). As was mentioned above, perhaps it's hooked up backwards (the pool company hooked it up.) But in any case, I'll retest, read your link, verify that it's hooked up properly, shock it tonight, and see what happens. I will likely shut off one return and direct the other out of the pool so that I can get a sample of the water coming directly from the return. Also, I'll be putting the o-ring in tonight.
I'm guessing the problem/issue is simple, but just frustrating right now. Will post in a day or so with new numbers. Thanks again.