Thanks so much for your help. So should I switch from the 3" Leslies chlorine tablets to a liquid chlorine in the gallon jugs?
My pool is 20 years old and until a few years ago, I always had to add muriatic acid to balance the ph. But then I had to start adding the soda ash instead if acid. I also went from 1 hopper of chlorine when the pool was new, to 3 hoppers and could never get the pool completely algae free. It still had the green algae in the scratches in the plaster (from dog clawing I think) and the Kreepy Krauley had algae I could never get off. I was brushing the pool every day about 20 minutes.
Then I tried a quart (half the recommended amount for my pool size) of the HTH Algae Free (Copper Sulphate) from Wallmart and within a week, there was not a trace of green algae anywhere. The pool was cleaner than it had been in years. And it stayed that way for a couple months, and with only 1 chlorine tablet hopper.
Then in the space of a week, the algae came back like crazy. I think I failed to keep the hopper full and the copper was about at its end anyway? So this is why I wanted to continue the copper treatment. The label on the bottle also said to continue with 16 oz/10,000 gallons of water every 3 months. I have not had the staining, and had been real happy with the algae being gone. But now you say don't use the copper algaecide. So I'm lost now.
I will follow the Pool School link you provided.
Thanks again