These systems do two different things, Spa Frog is a mineral systems and the ACE systems is a diamond doped electrode Saltwater Chlorine generator. The big downside to all of the mineral systems like Spa Frog is that they primarily work against algae, and do little to nothing against bacteria or viruses. The big down side to this is when using a chlorine system visible algae is a major warning sign something is going wrong in your water. By contrast the ACE system generates chlorine much the same as if you were to add chlorine manually to the water, it does this by passing an electrical current through a chlorine generating cell mounted inline in the plumbing, one of the big advantages of the ACE system over other many brands of SWCG's is the diamond doped electrodes generate mode potent chlorine radicals than standard electrodes, it also works at a lower salt concentration than most other SWCG's which makes the water less corrosive to metal plumbing fittings, etc.